Crunching win-loss records and Wild Card Points compiled by the twenty-six Class A teams over the past three seasons leads to
some pretty orderly results. The teams fall neatly into four groupings having similar characteristics.
Crunching the results in Class B, however, is more like having the top fly off a blender, splattering the ingredients all over the kitchen wall. There’s nothing neat or tidy about it (see chart below).

Because of shifts in teams’ positions from the Wild Card ranking to the Win Percentage ranking – for example, Ralston ranks 10th in Wild Card Point average but comes in at #16 in Win Percentage – it’s hard to come up with very many meaningful conclusions from the numbers.
But, of course, that won’t stop us from trying.
The starting point, of course, is at the top. Here we find the same seven teams leading both rankings: Skutt, Elkhorn, Mount Michael, Gretna, Pius, Beatrice and Nebraska City. Of those seven teams, six competed in the 2011 and 2009 state tournaments and five competed in the 2010 state tournament. (Elkhorn was assigned to Class A in 2010.)
The position of these seven teams in the two ranking categories varies quite a bit with Skutt coming out on top in Wild Card Points (.43.188) and Gretna ranking highest in Winning Percentage (.709). They each occupy fourth place in the other table.
The most likely factor causing the deviation between the rankings in the two tables is the number of games against Class A competition played by each team. Playing Class A teams is not a great way to improve one’s winning percentage but does provide a two-point bump in Wild Card Points for each game.
Thus, teams such as Skutt, Elkhorn and Pius that play a schedule that is heavy in Class A competition rank higher in the WCP table than in the Win % table. Teams that don’t play as many Class A teams, such as Gretna, Beatrice, Mount Michael and Nebraska City, are shifted the other direction – higher in Win % than WCP Avg.
That explanation probably also accounts for Ralston and Gross ranking much higher in WCP than in Win %.
In general, Class B teams that have been around a long time (i.e., since 2000 or earlier) tend to play a schedule that includes more Class A contests since many of their yearly pairings and tournament affiliations date back to a time when they had no other options.
Conversely, it’s harder for newer teams to schedule games against Class A teams since the dance cards of the upper-level teams were pretty full when the newcomers arrived at the party.
Another issue with the rankings is that they compare first-year teams that in some cases have as few as 10 games in their resume with established teams that have played 90 or more over the past three years.
To eliminate some of these quirky factors, we’re going to slice and dice the 26 Class B teams into five groups based on how long they’ve been playing baseball and examine the standings within each group. Such an approach helps identify the movers and shakers within these groupings.
Our first group we’ll label the “Legacy Group” – seven teams that have been around since before 2000. This group consists of Elkhorn, Douglas County West (formerly Valley), Gross, Pius, Ralston, Roncalli and Skutt.
Once we isolate this group from the others … presto change-o … we now have consistency between the rankings in the WCP table and Win % table because most of these teams (except for DC West) play a comparable slate of Class A opponents. The only deviation we have is a reversal of Ralston and Roncalli at #5 and #6, probably because Ralston plays a few more Class A opponents.

Skutt is the leader of this group in both WCP Avg. (43.188) and Win % (.622) over the past three years. Elkhorn and Pius are a solid #2 and #3, respectively, after which the Win % dips below the .500 mark. Gross and Ralston have been competitive in the post-season but their regular season numbers are not particularly glossy.
Roncalli has fallen from a 17-4 season (.810) in 2008 to 11-9 in 2009 to back-to-back 7-win seasons the past two years. DC West has struggled to be competitive with a total of 14 wins over the past three years.
How does this group compare to the newer programs? We haven’t gone through the brain damage of recalculating WCP Avg. and Win % for these teams against the 17 newer teams in Class B, but looking solely at post-season results, the answer would be “pretty good.”
Over the past three years the Legacy Group sent five teams to the state tournament in 2009, four in 2010 (when Elkhorn was in Class A), and four in 2011. So, for example, in 2010 and 2011, the teams in the Legacy Group claimed half of the eight berths in the state tournament while the other nineteen teams in the class duked it out for the remaining four slots.
During our three-year analysis period, the Legacy Group has claimed the state crown twice (Gross in 2009 and 2010), has had the runner-up all three years (Pius in 2009, Skutt in 2010, Elkhorn in 2011), has had the third-place team once (Skutt in 2011) and the fourth place team once (Skutt in 2009).
But, as we shall see below, despite the big headstart that the Legacy teams have had in establishing their programs, several newcomers are now challenging their supremacy.
The rapid expansion of high school baseball that eventually led to the formation of Class B began in 2004 when Nebraska City and Beatrice added the sport. Since that time, eighteen more teams have added baseball, including Plattsmouth for the 2012 season. Class B was established as a separate classification in 2008 with only 16 teams. For 2012 there will be 27 Class B teams, one more than in Class A.
Our second grouping of six teams includes the first wave of expansion that led to the formation of Class B: Nebraska City, Beatrice, Gretna (2005), Wahoo (2005), Blair (2006) and Seward (2006). No teams were added in 2007, so we’ll use 2006 as the end point for this group. All six teams have now been playing high school baseball for at least five years.
Here is how the Group 2 teams stack up:

In this group, Gretna, Beatrice and Nebraska City have all excelled over the past three years. In addition to posting the highest cumulative winning percentage in Class B over the past three years (.709) and the fourth-best Wild Card Point average (42.652), Gretna went undefeated (5-0) in the 2011 state tournament to claim its first title. The Dragons finished third at state the previous two years and have compiled a 9-4 (.692) state tournament record over the last three seasons, second in Class B only to Gross (10-1).
Beatrice ranks third in Class B in win percentage on the basis of strong seasons in 2009 (16-8 with a state appearance) and 2011 (15-5, including a 1-2 record at state). The Orangemen went 8-12 in 2010.
Nebraska City went 19-9 with a state tournament appearance in 2009, followed by a 20-9 season with a fourth-place finish at state the next year. Following the departure of a talented senior class in 2010 that included Logan Ehlers, the Pioneers missed qualifying for state in 2011, finishing 10-12.
Blair reached state and posted its only winning season in 2008, the program’s third year. After a 10-11 season in 2009, the Bears had the highest win total in their six-year history in 2010, going 15-11. Blair slid to 6-13 in 2011 for a .470 winning percentage over the past three years.
Seward doubled its win total in 2010 (from 5 to 10) to post the school’s best-ever season (10-11) but fell one win short of the .500 mark that year and again last year (8-9) for a .411 three-year average. The Bluejays will aim for their first winning season in 2012 under new head coach Brock Anderson.
Wahoo, which hasn’t had a winning season since the program went 9-8 in its first year, will get a boost in 2012 from the addition of Lincoln Lutheran to the Wahoo-Raymond Central co-op after finishing 6-16 last year.
Our third group, consisting of South Sioux City (2008), Norris (2008), Crete (2008), Waverly (2009) and Platte Valley (2009), has produced some high quality teams in a very short time span.

After going 4-12 in its inaugural season, South Sioux has had three consecutive winning seasons, averaging more than a dozen wins per year while frequently appearing in the Top Ten rankings. The Cardinals reached state in their third season (2010), picking up the program’s first-ever state tourney win before being eliminated, and were one win away from state last spring.
Like South Sioux, classmate Norris has made quick strides. Norris exceeded the .500 mark in its third season with a 12-9 record in 2010, and reached state in year four last spring. The Titans posted a 17-10 mark in 2011 to raise their win total over the past three years to 36, an average of 12 per year. Norris also became a regular in the Top Ten rankings last spring, ending the season at #7.
Third-year program Waverly broke the .500 mark for the first time last season in a big way with a 14-7 campaign and fell just short of earning a Wild Card berth at state. The Vikings finished the season ranked #9 in Class B.
Crete has lagged behind 2008 classmates South Sioux and Norris, winning just over a third of its games over the past three years (20-38.345). After back-to-back seven-win seasons by the Cardinals, new head coach Jeremy Fries will be looking to take Crete higher up the wins ladder in 2012.
Third-year program Platte Valley (21-36, .368) will also have a new coach in 2012, Gary Hollst, who’ll be looking to lead the three-school co-op to a more competitive record following a 6-10 finish last year.
Our fourth group consists of four programs that began play in 2010: Mount Michael Benedictine, Bennington, Pender / Bancroft-Rosalie and Arlington.

What Mount Michael has accomplished in its first two years of high school baseball is remarkable: a .700+ winning record, a district tournament championship, back-to-back state tournament appearances, two wins and a fourth place finish at state in 2011 and back-to-back Top Ten finishes (#7 in 2010 and #5 in 2011). It’s highly unlikely that any other team in the modern era of Nebraska high school baseball has accomplished as much in its first two year seasons.
In our overall cumulative three-year rankings, Mount Michael (.707) comes in second behind Gretna in Win % and third in WCP Avg. (42.657) behind Skutt and Elkhorn.
The other members of the Class of 2010 have had a successful entry into high school baseball, if not as splashy as Mount Michael’s.
Bennington got off to a very solid start in 2010, finishing with an 11-11 record, but slid backwards last year to a 5-14 finish.
Pender / Bancroft-Rosalie has made progress, improving to 7-10 in 2011 after going 4-13 in the program’s first season. The Pendragons will be bolstered this year by the addition of West Point – Beemer to their co-op, a move that more than doubles the student population from which talent will be drawn.
After a winless first season (0-18), Arlington progressed to 4-8 in 2011.
In our final group, the Class of 2011, Elkhorn South ranks first in WCP Avg. (38.920) on the basis of a challenging schedule and finishes second to Guardian Angels Central Catholic (formerly West Point Central Catholic) in Win %. The Storm pulled off an upset of Mount Michael during the regular season and shocked Waverly in the opening round of districts to claim the program’s first post-season win.

The three-school co-op made up of Guardian Angels Central Catholic, Dodge and Scribner-Snyder made the most of its eleven-game regular schedule despite two game being lost to bad weather. The result was a 6-3 record before a season-ending first-round district tournament loss to Crete by a score of 2-1. That’s certainly a good start for a new program and will keep spirits high going into the 2012 season.
Wayne started off its inaugural season with two straight wins before dropping their next nine. The Blue Devils rallied to win their regular season finale and also played eventual state runner-up Elkhorn tough in districts where their season ended with a 3-0 loss to the #1 seed. New head coach Adam Hoffman will build on that strong finish as he leads Wayne into its second season.
New head coach Roy Prauner will try to get Fort Calhoun off the schneid after the Pioneers went 0-16 in their first season. Offense is likely to be Prauner’s first priority as the Pioneers were shut out in seven of those losses.
So, now that we’ve broken Class B into five groups based on how long each has been playing spring ball, what does it all mean?
The basic storyline is that, unlike the settled landscape of Class A, Class B is the Wild, Wild West. The old established settlers and early pioneers better be on the lookout for new waves of gunslingers and claim jumpers who are bullying their way into the territory.
It should also be noted that recent legislative changes favor the newcomers. In 2011, the NSAA expanded the number of Class B districts from four to six. Prior to that, four district champions and four Wild Card teams advanced to state. Now, the stockpile of Class A bonus points earned by the Legacy Group is no longer as helpful in getting a berth at state. More of those old-timers will now have to shoot it out in the District Tournament Corral with the young guns -- and could possibly end up on Boot Hill.